00:03
I'm a historian of totalitarianism. I
00:05
look at fascist rhetoric. I've been
00:08
thinking about the sources of the worst
00:10
kinds of history for a quarter of a
00:12
century. Experts say the constitutional
00:15
crisis is here now. The Trump
00:16
administration deporting hundreds of men
00:18
without a trial. A massive purge at the
00:21
FBI to make people afraid of speaking
00:24
out against him.
00:31
I'm leaving to the University of Toronto
00:33
because I want to do my work without the
00:36
fear that I will be punished for my
00:39
words. The lesson of 1933 is you get out
00:42
sooner rather than later.
00:45
I've spent a lot of time in the last
00:47
decade trying to prepare people if Trump
00:50
were elected once, let alone twice. Look
00:54
what happened. Is this crazy? I did not
00:56
flee Trump. But if people are going to
00:58
leave the United States or leave
01:00
American universities, there are reasons
01:02
for
01:03
that. One thing you can definitely learn
01:05
from Russians is that it's essential to
01:08
set up centers of resistance in places
01:12
of relative safety. We want to make sure
01:14
that if there is a political crisis in
01:16
the US that Americans are organized.
01:19
We've just gotten started. You haven't
01:21
even seen anything yet. It's all just
01:23
kicking off.
01:25
My colleagues and friends, they were
01:27
walking around and saying, "We have
01:29
checks and balances, so let's inhale
01:31
checks and balances. Exhale checks and
01:34
balances." And I thought, "My god, we're
01:36
like people on the Titanic saying, "Our
01:39
ship can't sink. We've got the best
01:41
ship. We've got the strongest ship.
01:43
We've got the biggest ship. Our ship
01:45
can't sink." And what you know as a
01:48
historian is that there is no such thing
01:50
as a ship that can't sink.
01:54
The golden age of America has only just
01:59
begun. America has long had an
02:01
exceptionalist narrative. Fascism can
02:04
happen elsewhere, but not here. But
02:07
talking about American exceptionalism is
02:08
basically a way to get people to fall
02:10
into line. If you think that there's
02:12
this thing out there called America and
02:14
it's
02:16
exceptional, that means that you don't
02:18
have to do anything. whatever is
02:21
happening, it must be freedom. And so
02:24
then what your definition of freedom is
02:26
just gets narrowed and narrowed and
02:27
narrowed and narrowed. And soon you're
02:29
using the word freedom, but what you're
02:30
talking about is authoritarianism.
02:35
Tony Morrison warned us, "The descent
02:40
into a final solution is not a
02:45
jump. It's one
02:48
step and then another.
02:52
alone.
02:54
We are seeing those steps accelerated
02:59
right now.
03:01
There are some words in Russian in
03:04
particular that I feel help us to
03:08
understand what's happening in the
03:09
United States because we now have those
03:15
phenomena. It's the idea that the powers
03:17
that be can do anything they want to you
03:20
and you have no
03:22
recourse. This not knowing who is next
03:26
creates a state of paralysis in society.
03:30
The tough student whose visa was removed
03:33
because she co-authored an article in
03:36
the tough student newspaper.
03:40
I thought, what would I do if guys in
03:44
masks tried to grab my student? Would I
03:46
scream? Would I run away? Would I try to
03:49
pull the mask off? Would I try to
03:50
videotape the scene? Would I try to pull
03:52
the guys off of her? Maybe I would get
03:55
scared and run away. The truth is, I
03:57
don't know. Not knowing terrified me.
04:01
It's a deliberate act of
04:03
terror. It's not necessary. It's just
04:06
being done to create a spirit of us and
04:09
them.
04:13
It's a a word in Russian for corruption,
04:15
but it's larger than corruption. It
04:17
refers to a kind of existential state in
04:19
which not only everything, but everyone
04:22
can be bought or sold. Critics are
04:25
calling this a quidd proquo deal between
04:27
Adams and President Trump. I'm committed
04:30
to buying and owning Gaza. He made 2.5
04:33
billion today and he made 900 million.
04:36
There's an expression in Polish, I found
04:38
myself at the very bottom. And then I
04:41
heard knocking from
04:43
below in Russian that gets abbreviated
04:46
to there is no bottom.
04:49
We cannot allow a handful of communist
04:52
radical left judges to obstruct the
04:54
enforcement of our laws. What starts to
04:56
matter is not what is concealed, but
04:59
what has been normalized. There's no
05:02
limit to the depravity. President Trump
05:04
did not rule out the possibility of a
05:06
third term and the sadism. The White
05:09
House released this video titled ASMR,
05:12
illegal alien deportation flight. And
05:14
the cruelty that we are watching now
05:17
play out in real time. This facility is
05:20
one of the tools in our toolkit that we
05:22
will use.
05:24
You have to continually ask yourself the
05:27
question, is this okay?
05:31
Is there a line I wouldn't cross? Is
05:34
there something I would not do?
05:37
People say, "Oh, the Democrats should be
05:38
doing more. They should be fixing
05:40
things." But if you want the Democrats
05:42
to do things, you have to create the
05:44
platform for them. You have to create
05:46
the spectacle, the pageantry, the
05:48
positive energy, the physical place
05:50
where they can come to you.
05:55
Poland recently went through a shift
05:58
towards
06:00
authoritarianism. Unlike in Russia,
06:02
unlike in Hungary, the media remained a
06:06
place in Poland where you could
06:09
criticize the regime. And as a result,
06:13
democracy returned.
06:17
The moral of Poland is that our
06:20
democratic institutions, the media, the
06:23
university, and the courts are
06:26
[Music]
06:29
essential. You know, you're living in a
06:32
fascist society when you're constantly
06:36
going over in your head the reasons why
06:40
you're safe.
06:43
What we want is a country where none of
06:46
us have to feel that way.